{
  "verdict": "Approved reviewed source and actual-method regression; no concrete blocker.",
  "source_sha256": {
    "ERR_HQ.c": "8efc1b478ba7e0826c412bddeecd852097d55df269fd8c952e65a345a55865c1",
    "ERR_ConvoyService.c": "825a35f7afe485c1e5ddfc96dfff3498b39cce54dc19dce857b5d30fe5dc6557",
    "ERR_SupplyConvoyTactics.c": "dc3acdffc8ca48f11b131f66d30d679ca68f3b3004344bdc78723bc9305915e0",
    "tests/test_convoy_survivors.py": "db86f64be584d687afef8df8729dcd9c92dc13919d061699b2bb338782890f8b",
    "tests/test_convoy_lifecycle.py": "fc18679882f1666a38587d151aa368241c5af115f3a8269dca81eb2617eb8afc",
    "independent-green.log": "415fa2dfc0f1d7adcdaa1fd120af686b9771afc506487e9d4b1d1caaabc000cf",
    "independent-baseline.log": "f766935d0f68a1e3e50afc39ea1fef54c865366440e15087d992294eff045dab",
    "independent-lifecycle.log": "6e7f1708a5e9c0af68ffd0ace1edc33e99edff479cee2e6750bcaca1c94317ff"
  },
  "findings": [
    "Release retains only same existing HQ unit with CONVOY record/source and bound original status roster. Requires current active mode/command and non-stopping HQ.",
    "Living originals must still be present and attributable; duplicate, foreign/replacement agents and player ownership rejected. Vehicle path separately rejects Captured; team path requires no player-controlled group via HQ helper.",
    "No RegisterGroup, new roster, equipment grant or resource creation. Retaining same sampler preserves permanent released slots.",
    "Only pending convoy downlink is cancelled. ReleaseRecovery clears travel support role; LogisticsReservation is unchanged so accepted inventory uncertainty remains excluded until its existing owner settles.",
    "Normal Release still clears original route/intercept/crew holds and unpins record; failed retention/terminal/capture still unregisters.",
    "HQUnit.Eligible remains false while any conscious member seated; no forced dismount or automatic pathfinding outcome claimed."
  ],
  "native_evidence": {
    "file": "/home/jakub/devel/escapistsrereintroduced/docs/evidence/native-2026-10-02-convoy-loss-diagnostic/console.log.txt",
    "sha256": "de6bd49e3e89ee6cd582a54accd9ae04a12fc3c6e9c2f12b43d356de1b54f461",
    "lines": "774-787",
    "observation": "Released troop Ural slot2, vehicle alive, enemy group, nine originals alive/nonplayer/sameGroup; driver CanFight but aboard0; routeIndex0/19, now24603.3<deadline618363; taskReady1/taskStopped0.",
    "limitation": "Failure-time current state only. Does not establish earlier exact release trigger."
  },
  "tests_run": true,
  "native_runs_by_reviewer": false,
  "target_writes": false,
  "independent_tests": [
    {
      "name": "test_convoy_survivors.py proposal",
      "result": "PASS",
      "log": "independent-green.log"
    },
    {
      "name": "test_convoy_survivors.py baseline",
      "result": "Compiled then SIGABRT at original HQ retention assertion; expected regression red",
      "log": "independent-baseline.log"
    },
    {
      "name": "test_convoy_lifecycle.py proposed service",
      "result": "PASS",
      "log": "independent-lifecycle.log"
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Sampler/native boundary doubled in regression; actual Release, HQ retention, eligibility, ReleaseRecovery and ReleaseLogistics methods execute. No native post-fix survivor/report outcome claimed.",
    "Exact-token test proves cleanup API retains wrong-token claim then releases matching token; complete delayed inventory callback state machine not rerun in this bounded review."
  ],
  "patch_sha256": "0854cbc00212ebb0605253446ebac1894a3501330ca50fb97706ade5c2796703",
  "frozen_review_inputs_unchanged": true
}